Carbide motion alternatives?

(Ray Fleck) #1

curious what else folks are using.

it’s not insurmountable, but not being able to change tools and re-zero is frustrating.

0 Likes

(William Adams) #2

I used to use GrblController, and used bCNC for a while.

List at:

https://wiki.shapeoko.com/index.php/Communication_/_Control

2 Likes

(Julien Heyman) #3

I moved to Universal G-Code Sender, and never looked back. Way more flexible (but I understand why Carbide Motion locks the user to a simplified/unique workflow, it’s just easier for new users, and for Carbide support I guess).

A lot of folks use CNCjs.

5 Likes

(Gary Mitchell) #4

“I moved to Universal G-Code Sender, and never looked back”

yep

1 Like

(Ummm, not sure, but I’ll try...) #5

A vote for CNCjs from me.

Once you discover the flexibility of any of the alternatives…

3 Likes

(Ray Fleck) #6

I’ll have to check them out - looking for tool changes with re-zeroing Z. thanks for the suggestions

0 Likes

(Michael Oakley) #7

which post do you use for universal gcode sender from fusion

0 Likes

(William Adams) #8

Should be the same as for any other G-Code sender:

2 Likes

(Ummm, not sure, but I’ll try...) #9

@rayfleck, @neilferreri has written several macros for CNCjs that are floating around the forums here, you might check them out.

2 Likes

(mikep) #10

This one for fusion360:

1 Like

(nat) #11

I have used vectric aspire and fusion 360 with the carbide nomad. Both work fine. I come from using mastercam and have found that depending on what you are trying to do in the least amount of moves each software has its own strengths and limits.

Generally speaking the nomad interface is lacking in my mind. But it’s setup to be universal and avoid user errors. I like a more advanced setup that assumes you understand the pitfalls of cnc work.

Fusion 360 works well. Tool changes are there. But I often don’t do tool changes but use wcs coordinates based on the machine zero and run separate programs each time for each tool until I can string them all together if I need to run multiples of the same part. I do this so I can build each tools path and make sure I optimize that individual path.

Good luck!

2 Likes

(John Ellenberger) #12

Another Universal G-Code Sender user here. I have tried quite a few options and UGS is pretty solid, fairly simple to operate and well-known by the user community.

The only issue is figuring out which version to use, but that’s partly because I have the Sparkfun Bastardized Shapeoko which is stuck on 0.9 GRBL. I picked a version that works for me and stick with it. Using with Vcarve Professional (big $$).

Have not had good luck with Carbide’s Software in general. I keep a copies installed but pretty much never use it.

1 Like

(Bryan A Spiegel) #13

As Im getting more into designing for my S3, Im running into some points that are confusing, mostly, these different softwares.

Is there anyone who makes a pre-loaded and setup Raspberry Pi with cncjs, or Universal sender? Im creating in autocad, then fusion (I know autocad a lot better for 3d modeling) and have generating toolpaths down (I think) but getting this out into the real world, with tool changes and the required re-zero is where I hit my personal stops. So one setup to use the C3d calibration tool and has a tool library that can easily be edited without knowledge of coding would be great! Especially if I dont need a PC to use it… I can toss the surface tablet running my machine to other uses.

0 Likes

(Charles Van Noland) #14

I tried using Universal Gcode Sender back in the day and a few others but none of them could handle my huge CNC programs. Half of them would crash, the other half would finally load and draw the toolpath at a few seconds per frame while rotating the view. This was on a decent computer too. What ended up working the best for me was grblControl, which I believe has since been renamed to Candle. It can handle huge programs without breaking a sweat, supports probing/heightmap-offsetting, jogging via keyboard, etc… It’s pretty well-rounded and all that I have ever been able to use reliably.

0 Likes

#15

Changing tools and re-zeroing? Tell me about it! :blush: I’m still waiting for one of the forum members to stick one of those fancy Kress routers with an ATC (see Stepcraft) on their shapeoko and make it work with grbl. Any day now, I’d imagine.

By the way, Grbl-Panel and slowly into CNCjs for me. I use custom macros to automagically find my edges.

0 Likes

(William Adams) #16

I believe that’s described at one of the links at: https://wiki.shapeoko.com/index.php/Upgrade_Overview#Automatic_Tool_Changer

0 Likes

(mikep) #17

I suspect the supergerbil folks are thinking about it (they’ve made mention of tool change in the past.)

0 Likes