Covers for ballscrews and linear rails

Has anyone found a solution for covering the rails and ballscrews during running? I’m thinking sliding covers of some kind.

Every time I run the machine (yes always with a vacuum), I inevitably get chips of wood, plastic or metal flying onto the linear rails and screws. This cakes up (particularly wood dust) with oil and creates little sticky lumps that I then furiously clean after every session because I don’t want my rails or screws rusting.

Is there a solution to this? Do people:
a) Have a way to keep chips/dust away from the rails and screws?
b) Clean it meticulously after every session
c) Leave it and sort it once a week/month because it’s not that harmful?

Would love to hear other people’s thoughts - I just want to protect my machine for years to come whilst also enjoying running it regularly!

The search term you want is “way cover” and folks have discussed this, but mostly in the context of the Nomad:

https://community.carbide3d.com/search?q=way%20cover

The combination of reasonable feeds and speeds/material removal rate, dust collection, the wipers functioning as designed and cleaning up after each session should suffice — if it doesn’t, a photo showing what difficulty you are having?

2 Likes

We’ve replaced very few ballscrews in the past few years (it rounds down to zero).

The wipers on the rails and ballscrews do a good job unless the machine is caked in dust, which we rarely see if dust collection is being used. If you’ve got a shop vac running, then the dust is almost certainly minimal. We’d recommend wiping it down after use; you should be good to go.

7 Likes

Anecdotally, it has been my experience that way covers aren’t needed. Almost no dust gets on the machine.

I have even made some changes to the machine that let me cut wood faster than a shop vac can suck, but the rails and ball screws stay clean. I clean things when they get dirty, but I’ve only ever seen any crud on the X-axis ball screw and, even then, it’s really rare and is probably coming from me doing something else in the shop. The Y-axis screws are out of the way and the Z-plate seems to cover up the Z ball screw and rails and mostly prevent stuff from accumulating there.

I will very rarely find fine crud on things, but that’s just fine dust in the air settling down onto the ways and is a great reminder that I’m not running the air filter enough :slight_smile:

3 Likes

Thanks all, just went and took a few pictures for some context. I keep it well oiled following the maintenance video, and use the dust boot with vac almost all the time. These pics are pretty typical of what the machine would look like after an hour or so. Maybe I just need to get the toothbrush out, scrub it a bit and then stop worrying so much!

Help and support appreciated as I just want to keep my machine in good condition :slight_smile:




Years ago I saw this Vid. Never forgot it, my shop is full of things I may need some day, well so is my brain,

At least it is an idea that might be helpful to some

2 Likes

There are probably Shapeoko equivalent to these or design your own if you have a 3d printer. Ball Screw Wipers

I have used these for at least three years without replacement and they have kept things clean.

I printed using flexible PLA…

1 Like

The Shapeoko 5/5.1 machines already have wipers on the ballscrews. It probably won’t hurt to add another, but it shouldn’t be necessary.

3 Likes

@robinhartleywillows

That seems like allot of dust for a good working dust collection system? I’m just using a shop vac and small cyclone on a 5 gallon bucket and have nowhere near the amount of dust/debris on my S5 Pro especially for 1-2 hours?

1 Like

I’ve found Black Walnut produces a mix of good solid chips and that crud, even with reasonably good dust collection from a shop vac.

Please don’t settle for that.

Spend a bit extra and get a good quality vacuum/dust extractor/dust collection setup — in a noise-induced, migraine-fueled rage, I bought a Festool CT Midi and Oneida Ultimate Dust Deputy, and my lungs and everything in my basement, esp. the carpet are better off for it.

The nicer models of the DeWalt Stealthsonic as mentioned in a newsletter of ours a while back are such a good value that anyone who isn’t using something at least along those lines should grab one. If you want a cyclone, we offer:

(which is way more convenient to empty and more affordable than the Oneida)

4 Likes

I’ve got a DustRite cyclonic separator in front of the shop vac today, but I’m switching over to a 4” dust extraction system with a separator pretty soon, now that I’m in my own shop full time. Shop vacs are terrible for actually collecting dust. But they are nice and loud and warm.

The separator is absolutely worth it, otherwise the shop vac filter will be clogged in minutes. I combine all of that with a respirator at a fine particulate filter running whenever I’m in the shop. Fine dust is way too dangerous to let it near my lungs.

1 Like

I used to use my large ClearVue cyclone for the CNC but switched to the Stealthsonic because of the noise and length of some of these jobs.

I actually find that Iike the steathsonic and dust deputy better for the CNC. The big machine is reserved for the other tools now.

If the steathsonic craps out after 2 years who cares, it’s cheap.

1 Like

Thanks for the ideas and feedback so far - sounds like I might need to look at dust collection, as well as being a bit more proactive with cleaning. Luckily my daughter has just upgraded to a new toothbrush so the old one can scrub my machine :laughing:

Interesting links on the wipers and screw covers too - thank you.

1 Like

I run a dedicated Centec Quick Click separator and a 12 gallon locking collection bin with relief valve run off a Dewalt Stealthsonic 9 gallon vac and an anti-static hose running overhead to the sweepy. All available online pretty reasonable at Home Depot. The relief valve is key if the unit gets pugged up and keeps the collection bin from compressing though this has only happened once or twice. I also run HEPA filters and bags in the vac and a WEN overhead particulate filter. Keeps the shop clean. Quick wipe down of the rails and ball screws and a bit of the recommended oil keep everything running smoothly. I keep a second shop vac tied through a Rockler multi-port manifold to vacuum the bed and depending on the manifold position, run my router table and/or miter saw. Picked up a used Delta dust collector that I rebuilt with a pleated filter and magnetic couplers to run my table saw, planer, and tabletop jointer. All the above was less than $800 with the pleated filter being the most expensive part. Good luck!!

2 Likes

This topic was automatically closed 30 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.