Slight change in Z height while carving

I’m running VCarve Pro to Carbide motion on a Shapeoko 5 Pro. I love this machine, HOWEVER, I get very small changes in Z height while the carving is in process. Usually after several passes the Z height return to the proper level. This could happen again - maybe, maybe not. This occurs when flattening, stock removal, or during a 3D carve (2 images attached).

2 images - one is a large view and you can see this occurred



in 2 places while the other is a close-up. Height change is very small (maybe 0.001) but is noticeable and causes sanding.

Software is up to date, machine is trammed, axis are well lubricated & maintained.

Any suggestions?

Thanks

I also run Vectric to Carbide Motion. I have found that it is best to run a finishing pass at a 45 degree angle to the grain, especially in stringy woods (my favorite stringy wood is cypress). The fibers do not sever cleanly causing a “grab” on your cutter. Running with the grain in stringy wood doesn’t shear the fibers, it peels them.

3 Likes

We just had a similar post to this. The culprit was a hand pressing the machine down.

Do you recall if you were watching the carve and inadvertently leaned on the machine?

1 Like

This can be caused by poor wire harness connector contacts. I’ve had issues with my Z & X axis doing that sort of thing - just a couple lost steps here or there that doesn’t seem to really affect the final outcome much.
I found what finally got rid of it was changing out the connectors to something more robust that maintains good contact even while the gantry gets vibrated while moving fast. I actually think one of the pins on my Z-axis motor connector showed discoloration due to being heated from contact resistance - which means less power getting to the stepper motor to move it & maintain accurate & precise positioning & movement.

Thank you for the responses. I check all wiring & harnesses for any discoloration or signs of heated conditions, tightened every last bolt, screw, etc… and did a full maintenance of the machine. I then ran a test and got ZERO changes in height. I will watch and see if this occurs again and maybe I can narrow down the ultimate issue.

2 Likes

Please note that poor connector connections do not always give a visible indicator. The connectors are susceptible to vibrations during machine use & different vibrations can cause sudden intermittent loss of steps in a connector that is just barely making proper contacts. You can easily check your stepper motor connectors for issue by simply jogging an axis & then fiddling/gently flexing/stressing the connector a bit while it’s in motion. If the stepper stops/grinds/reverses from just slight stress on the connector, then it’s most likely causing lost steps during operations when vibrations or a dust colleciton hose hits it. Some users have found that zip-tieing the 2-sides of the connector together works. But securing the connectors in positions that protects them from being strained in any way during operation is adviseable.

1 Like

Will test this out this afternoon. I have a dust boot and then there’s the zip ties!

Folks -
I believe I found the problem. The placement of my dust hose! During a carve, I watch the dust hose follow insync with the spindle, not touching or interfering. Twice the hose appeared to cause a slight drag to the Z axis. When all was finished, that was where 2 inconsistencies were on the flay bottom. I removed the hose and left the Sweepy - perfect!! Ran 2 more jobs - perfect!!

Now to figure our a new, improved vacuum hose plan.

1 Like

@Zekesdog58

We appreciate the follow up on resolution of the issue. This makes troubleshooting future instances of problems for the forum members.