GWizard is on sale again, so I checked out the latest version. My impressions are:
It’s CADCAM function would be nice if it worked. Adjusting for machine rigidity would be nice if that worked. Being able to select “Alloys” in material “Families” would be nice if it made a difference. Knowing what criteria it uses to “optimize” cutting parameters would be nice, especially since it’s frequently wrong. I’m not trying to “stir the pot” or upset anyone, I just don’t understand it’s apparent popularity. 
4 Likes
That’s a really enthusiastic review, are you sponsored by GWizard?
7 Likes
Should be I guess - it’s the most positive review I could give! Maybe he’ll fix some of it. 
3 Likes
Well I’m not knocking it, it’s clear, concise and pretty much the TLDR.
2 Likes
I bought it on sale, a while back. So here’s my take FWIW. I don’t use any of it’s fine/rough slider nonsense, but the ability to import my tool list direct from fusion it’s kinda nice. Its rigidity correction is crap(for an SO3), and the whole CAD/CAM tab is somewhat confusing most of the time.
I do however like it as a F/S calculator. It’s quicker to manipulate and cleaner than Fusion, and I much prefer it to an Excel interface. I was using a modified NYCNC spreadsheet in the past and that was all function and no form (pun intended). So is it worth $150 for a S/F calculator… that’s tough to say.
It works well for what I use it for, and I’m not displeased with my purchase by any means. But then again you could just use Excel for free. So what you’re really paying for is the convenience of the UI and future support/updates. So would I buy it again, yes. Do I think it’s worth the price, ehhh probably not, It’s a splurge buy. Do I think its bells and whistles are worth it, no.
EDIT: This assumes that you have a good enough understanding of S/F to know what will work and what you want. You should know what Chip load is, or the relationship it has with speed, feed. Or the trade off between deep cuts with low engagement Vs. shallow cuts with high engagement. If that was all gibberish to you, then GWizard is 100% useless.
5 Likes
I didn’t realize it could do that. Is Amana’s Fusion360 tool database more complete than their Vectric database?
I can’t get GWizard to use the SFM and IPT for its calculations with a loaded tool. Can you?
Maybe because it takes a long time to come up with the wrong solution (screen flickers too)!
2 Likes
-
I know it’s crazy, new feature so still some bugs but really saves me work!
-
those are supposed to be the “vendor recommendations for that tool and material” you can change them in the tool crib somewhere… honestly its abstract. Their only really used as target values when you move around the tortoise/ hair slider, as soon as you “off road” and enter your own speed or feed it ignores those targets completely. If you know your target chip load then just enter it and lock it out then you can, say, adjust your speed to get an optimum feed rate you want.
-
I’ve never had a situation where I needed it, or where it would even give me something in the ballpark. Either I’m really dumb, or I have no idea how to get that tab to do anything useful.
2 Likes
IMO selecting the right tool for the job is important. Maybe I’m naïve, but my tendency would be to believe that competent tool manufacturers would know how best to use them. Wouldn’t it be nice if you could get GWizard to use those recommendations?
2 Likes
It does, as long as you stay in their recommended workflow. I feel like if I had a tormach, or prototrak Id get a lot more use out of it slider thing.
I’m right there with you on manufactures specs. But some people don’t have them posted so you need to have a feel for what will work for the tool you have. Although I find that there tends to be limitations in speeds/feed and rigidity on my SO3 so while I shoot for those numbers I often adjust to what has worked the best in the past. And maybe that’s good? maybe not? idk but it seems to work for me.
What is the application in the first and third picture you posted? I’m always collecting software…
1 Like
Shouldn’t GWizard allow that?
First is NOVO Web App – Kennametal
Second is https://hsmadvisor.com/
More info here - (@mikep is another GWizard fan) .
2 Likes
This topic was automatically closed after 30 days. New replies are no longer allowed.