Dog Face Catchall Tray - noses?

I’m trying to design catchall trays with dog faces, the idea is to customize them for my brothers and sisters to match their respective animals.

I’m using a 3/4 inch bowl bit to pocket, then a 60 degree v-bit for the details of the dog’s faces. I’m using Vectric Vcarve for these projects, and setting a flat depth on the v-carve toolpath if that matters.

Anyway, the noses look weird to me. I’ve tried different styles, for example this is my brother’s elkhound Loki:

My sister’s rescue CC:

Any my other sister’s golden (haven’t cut this one yet):

Looking for honest opinions, the noses look weird, right?

I have zero artistic talent so if anyone has suggestions I would love to hear them.

9 Likes

Looks really great, I would not worry about anything.

2 Likes

Agreed. I would leave it as is.
Nice job.

You could try changing how the Vector is carved instead of a V-Carve. Use the V-bit to do a contour cut “on” the vector. Maybe just do that for the nose?

In general, the way you have these setup, the carved parts are the dark parts of your design. They look funny because if you look at it too much, it doesn’t look like a dog’s nose because of the depth. We all know what a dog’s nose looks like and their not cut into a dog’s face. I think if you filled those with black epoxy, it’d look great.
That said, you’ll lose your mind if you keep looking at the dog’s nose. The only people that won’t think it looks great are you and all of us that you made stare at, and zoom in on, the dogs’ noses.
How’d you do the vector of their dog? Or are they just vectors of the same breed you found online?

2 Likes

Thanks for the feedback, you’ve pretty much put into words what was bothering me. The more I stare at the nose, the more ridiculous it looks.

These designs were created by using AI, specifically Bing Image Creator, which I then brought into Inkscape, and traced / edited / optimized, before importing into Vcarve. A little bit tricky do formulate a prompt to get a good design, but results are way, way better than I can do on my own.

The “dark parts” are the carved parts as you’ve pointed out.
For example, here is the Elkhound design before importing into Vcarve:

I’m sure you’re right, a fill with black epoxy or an inlay would probably look better. Hmmm.

I like that idea. I’m still just getting started with Vcarve so I’ll need to mess around to figure how to do that. Might need to redraw the nose into outlines instead of solid fill I’m guessing?

An quick oval inside the nose and breaking up the heavy outline on the top of the nose might reveal a carve more to your liking.

Thanks for this, I’m going to try it.

I guess part of my problem is I think in terms of vectors when designing, and don’t (yet) have the ability to think in terms of v-carve results.

This is a matter of an old graphic arts problem, “Figure–ground reversal” which we have discussed previously:

That’s it exactly Will, thank you.

Still, I think I need to modify that for what I’m doing here because this is a catchall tray, and I don’t think I want the geometry ‘proud’ of the bottom, it would be too thin and most likely easily damaged?

Going to see what I can do to “reverse” just the nose area, maybe.

A small inset should work to create an area which will then be at the desired height.

Just messing around, better, worse, or same?


Dog 1.zip (3.2 MB)

Dog 2


Dog 2
https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/8pcjdqzoy6k28dyk4hkzu/Dog-2.crv?rlkey=fl5f3o26ck6w0bjknq43x935x&st=l1rnvd2c&dl=0

Dog 2 Vectric file is too big to post.

I love dog art! Looks good!

These are awesome! Thank you.

Trial run of the new style nose:

8 Likes

Dog noses are weird in general. Dog noses can detect infra-red heat, this allows puppies that haven’t opened their eyes to find mom’s teat. Dogs also have directional smell allowing them to quickly and accurately determine where a smell is coming from. In addition to this they can also tell if a scent is older or newer helping them track. There is a gland in the dogs nose that no one knows its function.

However, this dog knows your trays look amazing.

3 Likes

Beautiful image of a golden. Lost ours a few years ago and miss her. Would you be willing to share the file? Thanks.

@Chris-A

Happy to share!

I’ve attached the SVG file below, which was created and edited in Inkscape.

I’m also going to try to attach a ZIP archive of the CRV file, which was created and edited in Vectric Vcarve. Hopefully that works.

There are slight differences between the two as far as vectors are concerned, as edits are usually necessary after importing an SVG into Vcarve.

drawing

cherry final.zip (1.6 MB)

2 Likes